Showtime analysis
Phew, yesterday was so chock full of news eh? Now that the excitement has died down there has been analysis of the whole event. Here are some that I found interesting.
Update: John Gruber from Daring Fireball has posted the best analysis I’ves seen so far and I just had to link to it. Check it out.
Dan Frakes from Playlist/Macworld wrote a great article in which he discusses Apple’s foray into the living room. He looks at what movies will mean for Apple and offers a good explanation on why Apple went against their traditional secrecy and announced a product that wasn’t ready yet.
That Apple talked about the iTV well before its release was unusual, given the company’s famous secrecy. But in the context of the event, it was likely a prudent move. First, it showed that Apple is taking the TV and living room seriously, rather than as an afterthought, at a time when more and more people are looking for ways to get their growing collection of digital content out of their computer and into the rest of their homes.
But just as important in the wake of Amazon’s recent foray into downloadable movie sales, the iTVâ€â€or whatever it will be called when it arrives next yearâ€â€gives Apple a significant leg up on other services by offering a way to enjoy purchased digital media in locations other than sitting at your computer or staring at a tiny portable screen. And it’s likely that Apple’s sneak peek was at least in part aimed at the movie studiosâ€â€to convince them that getting their movies into the iTunes Store would be desirable.
I highly recommend reading the whole article (link).
While lots of Mac fans are raving about the announcements, I found some comments that kind of put things in perspective.
Read/Write Web says that the iTunes Store + iTV combo isn’t really a winner because of a lack of movies (only Disney?) and lack of DVR capabilities. They’ve got a point… (link).
Scoble says that this time Apple is the copycat! The iTV interface is a lot like the Windows Media Centre PC interface, he says (link).
One blogger compares the quality of movies downloaded from the iTunes Store with those ripped with Handbrake. The results? Handbrake is better. That makes me feel a little better that the iTunes Store still isn’t available here, but I’m just bitter. The dude’s site got digged, so here’s a mirror.
Finally, analysts are split about Apple’s foray into the living room. PaidContent has excerpts from everyone.
In other news, TUAW welcomes iTunes’ new look. Wonders if this is what Leopard will look like finally. On the other hand, David Sandler critiques iTunes 7 UI. I thought that it looks nice, but that’s the quality of opinion from a non-designer like me haha.
For more analysis you can check out the latest episodes of the Macworld podcast which features a discussion by the Macworld editors Chris Breen, Jason Snell and Dan Frakes what the Showtime announcements mean for Apple. Also, check out the Mac Roundtable Podcast by Mac podcasters Joseph Nilo from the MacPro Podcast, Tim Verpoorten from MacReviewcast, Steve Stanger from the The Mac Attack, and Adam Christianson from the MacCast.
5 Comments
Nice source of info!
The one about Apple copying Microsoft deal is a lame rant. Apple is definitely innovative in a lot of areas, but saying that Apple is copying on something small such as UI-style, is the same as saying that they also copied the key layouts for the original QWERTY typewriter, or Toyota copying the wheel.
The key to Apple’s innovations is not that they ‘invented’ something original – rather, they utilised a bold new feature never before thought of by others – such as the iPod + iTunes combo. SURE, MP3 players has been for around, but never one with all-round seamless integration until the iPod came along – that’s INNOVATION. It’s mostly about putting 1+1=3 rather than telling people your ’1′ is the ultimate innovation.
Wow Ian, that is probably the best comment ever. I love the comeback about copying the wheel haha!
You’re absolutely right. Apple’s strength is innovation. They don’t mind being second to the party, but when they do it, they do it with style. What’s the point of being first if you screw up anyway? Hmm.. reminds me of Amazon Unbox‘s debut.
Thanks for pointing out the Unbox to me – I didn’t know they had that service in the first place!
Upon reading more on the Unbox article, I noticed that while it was definitely Amazon’s problem with its software (fixable with updates) the other part of the problem is all too familiar – it has to do with how Windows manages software installations. I believe that most other software services that users have to download from the Internet will come across similar problems as well.
Does Unbox has Mac support? (I’m predicting ‘no’ as the answer)?
You’re right. It doesn’t have Mac support, and no announcement of when it will.
I get lots of my tech news from the Buzz Out Loud podcast. I absolutely love those guys and I highly recommend checking them out.
bmw 1997 z3…
news…
Leave a Reply